Patentability
GuideTutorialStep 5 of 5

Patentability

Sonoma’s patentability check attacks your invention the way an examiner, an engineer and a competitor would, scores it against eight gates, and ends in a decision with what to do next.

Run the check

In Patentability, choose Run test. The check is included in the search’s credit and takes around ten minutes; you can leave the page while it runs. Sonoma:

  1. builds a dossier and a brief of your invention from the write-up and the charted references;
  2. asks independent probes, which play an engineer of ordinary skill in the art and never see your write-up, what they would propose for the same problem;
  3. runs a blind examiner, with its own short fresh search (again with generic queries), an engineering pre-mortem and a competitor’s design-around;
  4. scores the result, applies the gates and reads the decision from the decision table.

The decision

The banner shows the decision, the row of the decision table that produced it and why. The meter shows the Patentability Readiness Index (PRI), from 0 to 100, with thresholds at 45, 60 and 75.

DecisionWhat it means
FILE-TRACKEvery hard gate passes, no gate fails and the PRI is 75 or more. Take it to a registered patent attorney or agent.
FILE-TRACK pending inventor memoThe same, except that your conception memo is missing. Record it (below).
DEVELOPPromising, but close a gap first: how it works, evidence that it works, or what the write-up discloses. Also the result when every hard gate passes and the PRI is 60–74.
PIVOTAn obviousness or eligibility ground stands, or every hard gate passes but the PRI is 45–59. Change, combine or narrow the idea, then check again.
PARKThe business case fails (V8). Shelve the idea for now.
DROP / PARKThe invention is anticipated, or no other row applies, for example because a fatal ground stands or the PRI is below 45. Drop the idea or shelve it.

The exact rules are in the decision table.

Scores and probes

CriterionWeight
Novelty (N)20%
Non-obviousness (O)30%
Enablement (EN)15%
Eligibility (EL)10%
Technical effect (TE)10%
Commercial value (CV)10%
Breadth (BR)5%

Each criterion is scored 0–5 with a written reason. Eligibility is scored only for software-related inventions, including AI and business methods; otherwise it shows N/A and is left out of the PRI.

Independent probes show how many of three fresh probe runs proposed your mechanism from the prior art alone (P1), and from the prior art plus the known limitation of today’s approaches (P2). 0 is best: the higher the count, the more obvious the idea looks.

Gates

The hard gates (H-N, H-O, H-EN, H-EL, H-TE, H-ATTACK and H-HUMAN) are shown in the Scores tab. They pass when the matching score is at least 3, when no fatal examiner ground or pre-mortem cause stands, and when your conception memo is recorded.

The Gates tab lists the eight gates, each PASS, CONDITIONAL or FAIL with its evidence: V1 Eligible, V2 Works, V3 New, V4 Non-obvious, V5 Disclosed, V6 Definite, V7 Human-invented and owned, and V8 Valuable. Below them are the obviousness traps that were checked and any green flags. See Gates in Concepts.

Examiner, pre-mortem and design-arounds

  • Examiner: the strongest grounds of rejection under 35 U.S.C. 102, 103, 101 and 112, each rated FATAL, ARGUABLE or CLEAR, with references and reasoning.
  • Pre-mortem: why the invention might fail in practice, classed as FATAL, REPAIRABLE or DISCLOSURE GAP, each with a fix and a question for you.
  • Design-arounds: how a competitor could avoid each element, at what cost, and how to tighten the claim.
  • Files: every Markdown output of the check, opened on its own page.

Your conception memo

In the Scores tab, write a conception memo in your own words: for each claim, what you conceived and how (at least 40 characters). Choose Record. H-HUMAN passes, V7 is checked again and the decision is recalculated straight away, without running the check again. The memo is kept with the search and carries over when you re-run the check.

Until the memo is recorded, H-HUMAN fails. A check that would otherwise be FILE-TRACK shows FILE-TRACK pending inventor memo, and one that would reach DEVELOP or PIVOT only on its PRI (60–74 or 45–59) shows DROP / PARK instead.

Changing the references or the write-up marks the check as out of date. Re-run uses one of the step’s 2 re-runs.