Concepts
The terms Sonoma uses on screen and in the reports, and where each rule comes from.
Categories
Categories follow PCT Administrative Instructions §§ 505 and 507 (MPEP § 1844.01), applied to the searched features.
| Code | Meaning |
|---|---|
| X | Taken alone, the searched features cannot be considered novel or inventive. |
| Y | Combined with other such documents, in a way obvious to a skilled person, the features lack an inventive step. |
| A | Defines the general state of the art. |
| E | A patent document filed earlier but published on or after the cut-off: potential 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(2) art. |
| P | Published after a claimed priority date but before the actual filing date (intervening). |
| L | Cited for another reason, such as establishing another citation’s date. |
Date classes
| Badge | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Before cut-off | Published before the effective filing date, per the record: 102(a)(1). |
| Before cut-off · estimate | The same, but the date is an estimate. Confirm it before relying on it. |
| Year … from number | Only the year is known, from the publication number. |
| On cut-off | Published on the effective filing date: not prior art under 102(a)(1). |
| Earlier filed · 102(a)(2) | A U.S. document published later but effectively filed before the cut-off. |
| Check filing date | Published after the cut-off; prior art only if filed earlier, which needs the filing and priority dates. |
| Intervening | Between the claimed priority date and the filing date. |
| After cut-off | Published after the effective filing date. |
| Date unverified | No reliable date. State of the art only, not relied on as prior art (MPEP 2128). |
| No cut-off | The effective filing date is not set, so dates can’t be classified. |
A verified date entered on a reference page overrides the date the search found.
Mapping values
D: the reference discloses the feature. P: partly. A dot: not found. A passage marked Verified verbatim was found word for word in the stored text; an unverified quotation is never cited in the documents.
KSR rationales
Combinations name one of the rationales in MPEP 2143(I):
| A | Combining prior art elements according to known methods to yield predictable results |
| B | Simple substitution of one known element for another to obtain predictable results |
| C | Use of a known technique to improve similar devices, methods or products in the same way |
| D | Applying a known technique to a known device, method or product ready for improvement to yield predictable results |
| E | “Obvious to try”: choosing from a finite number of identified, predictable solutions with a reasonable expectation of success |
| F | Known work in one field prompting predictable variations for use in the same or a different field |
| G | Some teaching, suggestion or motivation in the prior art leading to the claimed invention |
PRI
The Patentability Readiness Index is a weighted average of the seven scores, scaled to 0–100: novelty 20%, non-obviousness 30%, enablement 15%, eligibility 10%, technical effect 10%, commercial value 10% and breadth 5%. A criterion marked N/A is left out of the average. The scores come from the analysis; the PRI is then calculated from them with a fixed formula, and the decision table uses its thresholds of 45, 60 and 75.
Gates
| Hard gate | Requirement | Gate |
|---|---|---|
| H-N | Novelty ≥ 3 | V3 New |
| H-O | Non-obviousness ≥ 3 | V4 Non-obvious |
| H-EN | Enablement ≥ 3 | V5 Disclosed |
| H-EL | Eligibility ≥ 3, when it applies | V1 Eligible |
| H-TE | Technical effect ≥ 3 | V2 Works |
| H-ATTACK | No FATAL examiner ground or pre-mortem cause | V2, V3, V4 |
| H-HUMAN | Your conception memo is recorded | V7 Human-invented and owned |
V6 Definite and V8 Valuable have no hard gate; they are assessed with evidence in the Gates tab.
Decision table
The first row that matches decides.
| Row | Decision | When |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | DROP / PARK | V3 fails (anticipated), or a FATAL ground survives the re-attack |
| 2 | PIVOT | An obviousness ground stands (V4 or H-O fails) |
| 3 | PIVOT | Eligibility fails (V1 or H-EL) |
| 4 | DEVELOP | V2, V5, V6, H-EN or H-TE fails, or a repairable cause is open |
| 5 | PARK | The business filter fails (V8) |
| 6 | FILE-TRACK pending inventor memo | Every hard gate passes except H-HUMAN, and PRI ≥ 75 |
| 7 | FILE-TRACK | Every hard gate passes, V1–V8 pass or are conditional, and PRI ≥ 75 |
| 8 | DEVELOP | Every hard gate passes and PRI is 60–74 |
| 9 | PIVOT | Every hard gate passes and PRI is 45–59 |
| 10 | DROP / PARK | No earlier row matched |
Human inventorship
AI helps with the search and the analysis, but inventorship stays with people. Your per-claim conception memo is recorded in the search’s human log (patentability/07_human_log.md) and decides H-HUMAN and, with its evidence, V7.